paint | jamie's home blog

Let me begin this post by addressing the furniture purists. Hello, you. You’re smart, and you have valid opinions, and I love that you’re passionate about maintaining the original beauty of pieces. Because someone put their blood, sweat, and tears into designing them in all their glory. So you shouldn’t mess with that. I get it. I feel you. I mostly agree with you. But this dresser… THIS. DRESSER. was too far gone, and it was paint, or ~~get off the pot~~ trash it. I promise I didn’t mess up a good thing. I made a mediocre thing great. There were, however, some bumps in the road on this journey. Come along with me and see… Sorry in advance for some of the more blurry pics.

Uhhh, how long ago did I buy this dresser? Oh right… like three years ago. I found it via craigslist. Three years, and I’m just getting around to giving it a makeover. Sorry, dresser.

This MCM dresser has a beautiful masculine shape, and great bones. Dovetailing, wooden drawer glides, sturdy build, tapered feet, gorgeous hardware, simple decorative fluting. Overall a great piece…

The veneer surrounding the piece was a MESS. Scraped, chipped, scratched.

At some point, a previous owner sought to paint it, I guess, because there was a big white unfinished spot on one edge… And the color… The color was atrocious. If I’m spitball guessing, I’d say that someone, at some point, polyurethane’d the heck out of it, which left it with a stale, burnt, pale yellow hue.

The outer surfaces were beyond repair, so I decided to paint them. Guys, I made my own chalk paint, and I messed up…

I used a diy chalk paint formula that calls for plaster of Paris, and when I picked out a perfect, very dark navy blue, I didn’t account for the fact that the powdery white plaster of paris would *significantly* lighten the color. I tried to convince myself that it wasn’t awful for weeks, but really, I hated it.

So when I was ready to pick the project back up, I went with a crispy bright white. A – I thought it would look amazing and B – there was no worry of the plaster of Paris changing the color. I used this formula for the chalk paint, and used a sample size of Valspar Polar White for the color.

I was wayyy happier with the white. And really, despite hating the first color I picked, I loved using the diy chalk paint. It takes some getting used to (the texture is different, even when compared to professionally mixed chalk paint). It was almost like painting icing on a cake. A lot of icing on a very large cake. I recommend making your coats as thin as possible with chalk paint. It’s super thick and has amazing coverage. I covered the crazy blue with just THREE COATS of white. No priming, no sanding, straight up paint on a brush, applied to the dresser. Three coats, plus one coat of paste wax on top to protect the finish. How’s that for a slice of fried gold?

For the drawer fronts, I used Minwax Polyshades in Mission Oak, in a satin finish. A flat finish may have been a better choice considering the chalky flat finish you get with chalk paint, but the difference in finishes isn’t noticeable to me. I did sand these before applying the stain to remove the existing layers of poly and general yuck. The wood veneer on the drawers was in good condition, and it was thick, so it held up to a moderate session with my power sander.

The big plus of the polyshades product (no, this post isn’t sponsored) is that you have your stain and poly all in one step. Efficient and easy. Two coats, and I was good to go.

The end result? A super handsome, two-toned, MCM dresser, upgraded from ick. I am ecstatic with the outcome of this long-awaited (if only by me) project! Side note – I also switched out my green window-pane mirror (which was too small for the wall) for a six piece gold sunburst set… have mercy. What a big difference!